Starting your own direct-pay or private-pay practice is exhilarating—you’re free from insurance headaches and can finally practice medicine on your terms. But after a few months (or even years), you might notice something frustrating… your patient panel isn’t growing as fast as you expected.
What’s going wrong? More importantly, how do you fix it?
Here are the most common pitfalls that stall practice growth—and exactly what you can do to turn things around.
🚨 Pitfall #1: No Clear Marketing Strategy
“I’ve tried everything, but nothing seems to work.”
Many clinicians take a scattershot approach to marketing—running Google ads, posting on social media, joining networking events—but they don’t track what’s actually bringing in patients.
The result? Burnout, wasted money, and no real growth.
✅ How to Fix It: Get Intentional With Your Strategy
Instead of doing more, do less—but do it better.
✔ Track where your leads come from – When a patient calls, ask: How did you hear about us? Keep a simple spreadsheet or use a CRM to log this data.
✔ Double down on what works – If 80% of your patients come from referrals, focus on building more referral relationships instead of wasting money on ads.
✔ Be patient with SEO – Unlike ads, SEO (search engine optimization) takes time but pays off long-term. Start now by optimizing your website for searches like “[Service] in [Your City].”
🚀 Quick Win: For the next 30 days, track every single new patient’s lead source. By the end of the month, you’ll know exactly where to focus your efforts.
My Sales & Marketing Academy teaches about this further and some tools for you to use.
🚨 Pitfall #2: Relying Too Much on Social Media
“I post every day, but no one is booking appointments.”
Social media is great for brand awareness—but it rarely converts directly into booked patients.
If you’re spending hours making reels but seeing no return, it’s time to rethink your approach.
✅ How to Fix It: Make Social Media Work for You (Not the Other Way Around)
✔ Use social media to build trust, not as your main lead source – Instead of “selling,” use it to educate, engage, and drive traffic to your website.
✔ Capture leads off social media – Offer a free resource (e.g., “3 Reasons Why DPC Saves You Money” as a PDF download) and collect emails.
✔ Direct people to your website – Every post should include a call to action (“Want to see if my practice is right for you? Book a free consult at [your website].”)
🚀 Quick Win: Instead of spending 5+ hours a week making social media posts, use one of those hours to improve your website’s homepage. Social media should support your marketing, not be the only strategy.
🚨 Pitfall #3: Lack of Local Presence
“I have a great website, but people in my city don’t know I exist.”
In the direct-pay model, relationships matter. If you’re not actively engaging with your local community, you’re leaving a ton of growth potential on the table.
✅ How Fix It: Get Involved in Your Local Community
✔ Partner with local businesses – Many would love to offer your services as a perk to employees.
✔ Attend networking events – Join your Chamber of Commerce, BNI, or small business meetups—not to “sell,” but to build connections.
✔ Do in-person educational talks – Offer free community workshops on stress, weight loss, or chronic disease management.
🚀 Quick Win: Reach out to one local business this week and introduce yourself. Offer a free “Lunch & Learn” for their employees—no sales pitch, just valuable education.
💡 Best targets in my opinion? Real estate offices! Many agents are 1099 workers with little to no insurance, and the stress of entrepreneurship can take a serious toll on their health.
🚨 Pitfall #4: Weak Website & Poor Online Visibility
“People visit my website, but they don’t book.”
A cluttered, confusing, or slow website is like having a storefront with a locked door. Patients won’t call if they don’t understand your services.
✅ How To Fix It: Optimize Your Website for Conversions
✔ Clear messaging – Your homepage should instantly tell visitors: Who you are, what you offer, and how they can book an appointment.
✔ Frictionless booking – Make it easy to schedule a consult (BIG button that says “Book a Free Meet & Greet” or "Schedule an Appointment" ).
✔ Speed & mobile-friendly design – 70%+ of website visitors are on their phones. If your site is slow or hard to navigate, they’ll leave.
🚀 Quick Win: Pull up your website on your phone right now. If you had never heard of your practice before, would you know what to do next? If not, fix it.
🚨 Pitfall #5: Not Following Up With Leads
“People reach out but don’t book—or they ghost me after a visit.”
Many clinicians assume that if someone doesn’t book right away, they weren’t interested. But the reality? Most people need multiple touchpoints before committing.
✅ How to Fix It: Follow Up Like a Pro
✔ Send a follow-up email within 24 hours of a meet and greet or first time appointment – Thank them and remind them how you can help.
✔ Automate a simple email nurture sequence – If someone downloaded your free guide, send 3-4 follow-up emails over the next few weeks.
✔ Check in after 30 days – A simple “Just checking in—do you have any questions?” can reignite interest.
🚀 Quick Win: If you’ve had a visit that didn’t convert, reach out to those leads today. A quick check-in might turn them into your next patient or client.
Final Thoughts: Stop Guessing, Start Growing
Growing your practice isn’t about working harder—it’s about working smarter.
If your patient panel isn’t growing, chances are you’re:
❌ Doing too many things without tracking results
❌ Relying too much on social media
❌ Not engaging locally
❌ Not optimizing your website
❌ Not following up with potential patients
📌 What to do next? Pick ONE fix from this list and implement it this week. Small, focused improvements lead to big results over time. 🚀
Comments